One focused collection. ● Live now
Home/About
Cape Cod · Since 2009

FROM BAR
COVERS TO
FIVE ALBUMS.

Our story

A COVER BAND
THAT KEPT GOING.

This is the Highly Suspect store. Every design here comes from our records and our name, on tees, long sleeves, crewnecks and hoodies, with kids' and youth sizes too.

We formed in 2009 on Cape Cod, Massachusetts, as a bar cover band. Johnny Stevens and the twins Ryan and Rich Meyer went to Dennis-Yarmouth Regional High School in South Yarmouth. After the EPs First Offense and The Gang Lion, we moved to Brooklyn and recorded The Worst Humans with producer Joel Hamilton in 2012. Matt Kofos and Mark Schwartz have been in the lineup since 2019.

Our first studio album, Mister Asylum, came out in 2015 and was nominated for Best Rock Album at the Grammys, with "Lydia" up for Best Rock Song. The Boy Who Died Wolf followed in 2016, then MCID in 2019, The Midnight Demon Club in 2022 and As Above, So Below in 2024.

Every design in this store comes from that story: our name, our records, the art we've made along the way. Each one comes on tees, long sleeves, crewnecks and hoodies, with kids' and youth sizes too.

Highly Suspect together in front of the stage before a show
2009Formed on Cape Cod
5Studio albums
3Grammy nominations
4.8★Avg rating
01

A size chart
on every product

Every product page has its own size chart, so you can check the fit before you order.

02

Every design
has a story

Each design comes from our name or our records, and its product page tells you what it shows.

03

Sizes for
the whole family

Unisex cuts for adults, plus kids' tees and youth crewnecks and hoodies with the same designs.

04

Black
or white

Every design comes on black and on white, so it fits whatever you already wear.

LOUD MUSIC.
LOUD MERCH.

Explore the shop →

Track your order

Enter your order number and the email you used at checkout.